Skip to content

GERMAN GRAMMAR · B1

German passive: a process, a state or an obligation?

Use werden plus a participle to describe a process, and sein plus a participle for a resulting state in the patterns shown here. With a modal, keep the passive infinitive: muss geschlossen werden. An instruction to close something does not say it is already closed.

Practise this topic →

This lesson requires course access or an eligible free trial.

What is happening, or what condition is it in?

A process description focuses on an action. A state description focuses on the resulting condition. It need not identify who caused that state or exactly when. Some participles also act like adjectives, so avoid treating every combination with sein as proof of one universal analysis.

Das Tor wird geschlossen. Das Tor ist geschlossen.

The gate is being closed. The gate is closed.

Keep both parts after a modal

In a passive requirement, the participle names the action and the infinitive werden supplies passive meaning. The modal is the conjugated verb and agrees with the subject. Leaving out the infinitive produces an incomplete construction.

Die Tore müssen geschlossen werden.

The gates must be closed.

Separate instructions from results

A requirement can still be unfulfilled. A state report describes what holds now. Reading that difference matters in ordinary instructions: do not mistake something that needs checking for something already checked.

Das Tor muss geschlossen werden. Das andere Tor ist schon geschlossen.

The gate must be closed. The other gate is already closed.

Practise this pattern

The matching block includes guided questions, a separate mastery check and spaced review. These tasks practise specific grammar patterns and do not certify a complete language level.

Practise this topic →

This lesson requires course access or an eligible free trial.

Related grammar

References

Original explanations and examples informed by grammar references. Level placement is an editorial teaching choice.